Fielder just barely advanced to the second round with five home runs in the first, one more than the eliminated Carlos Gonzalez (Colorado Rockies) and Andrew McCutchen (Pittsburgh Pirates). His 11 in the second round gave him a berth in the final.
Bautista hit 11 in the first round, but only two in the second. He had to beat Mark Trumbo (Los Angeles Angels) in a swing-off for the right to face Fielder.
Carlos Beltran (St. Louis Cardinals) was eliminated after two rounds with a total of 12.